Regulators Appear to Endorse Alternative Credit Scoring
A joint statement from the nation’s biggest banking regulators expressed cautious optimism toward emerging decisioning models that could generate more auto loans.

Kathy Kraninger is director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which joined four other federal banking regulators in offering a largely positive opinion of alternative credit data in a joint statement this week.
WASHINGTON — The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and four other federal regulatory agencies released a joint statement offering tempered support for the use of alternative data in credit decisioning processes, including applications for auto loans.
Alternative credit data focuses less on credit history and more on cash flow, measuring activity relating to “nonfinancial” information such as bill and rental payments and bank account balance history. The use of alternative data in “second look” platforms for applicants who fail to qualify under traditional scoring models has grown over the past decade as creditors have sought new ways to reach more borrowers.
Read: Auto Loans and Leases Up 1% in Q3
The CFPB was joined as a signatory by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, and the National Credit Union Administration.
“Using alternative data may enable consumers to obtain additional products and/or more favorable pricing/terms based on enhanced assessments of repayment capacity,” the statement reads, in part. “These innovations reflect the continuing evolution of automated underwriting and credit score modeling, offering the potential to lower the cost of credit and increase access to credit.”
The alternative model generated 27% more approvals and reduced annual percentage rates by an average of 16%.
The statement follows the August release of a CFPB-commissioned study, undertaken in partnership with Upstart Network, an alternative scoring technology provider, that set out to compare decisioning results from traditional and alternative models.
Analysts found the alternative model generated 27% more approvals and reduced annual percentage rates by an average of 16%; no bias toward any race, ethnicity, or gender was detected.
However, “As with prior developments in the evolution of credit underwriting, including the advent of credit scoring, the use of alternative data and analytical methods also raises questions regarding how to effectively leverage new technological developments that are consistent with applicable consumer protection laws,” the regulators noted, listing unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices standards and the Fair Credit Reporting Act as examples.
Originally posted on F&I and Showroom
More Dealer Ops

Ladies and Gentlemen, This Is a Dealership: Why the Fundamentals Still Decide Who Wins
A teaching moment by a legendary football coach happens to apply perfectly in the auto retail space. Learn what it is and how to use it to your store’s advantage.
Read More →
Timing the Market Can Hurt Long-Term Program Performance
For dealer-owned reinsurance entities, avoiding volatility entirely can mean falling behind inflation and missing market rebounds that drive long term surplus growth. Missing just a handful of strong market days can materially impact cumulative returns—an important reminder for long horizon trust and investment strategies.
Read More →
Dealer Ads and the FTC
The agency has made it clear in recent enforcement actions and warnings, in auto retail and other industries, that advertised prices must include all nonoptional costs to the consumer.
Read More →
Used Autos Supply Dwindles
The March shopping surge, despite high prices, cut into inventory by the most since the thick of the pandemic, Cox Automotive analysts calculated.
Read More →
Managing Risk Effectively Through Changing Times
The variables influencing risk pricing have changed significantly over the past five years. Being proactive and responsive to emerging trends is not optional but essential.
Read More →
Survey Reveals What Won't Fix What's Breaking Car Sales
AutoPayPlus says extra-long auto loans are trapping consumers and threatening the dealer trade-in cycle, and that the industry is leveraging the wrong tools to combat high MSRPs.
Read More →
IA American Appoints Two Execs
Senior vice presidents of the company's agent and dealer channels chosen to support general agents and help auto dealers with sales and performance.
Read More →
Cox Automotive Acquires Inspection Firm
Full ownership of Alliance Inspection Management, or AiM, meant to unlock growth for Manheim inspection capabilities
Read More →
Assurant Expands Partnership With Holman
Extended collaboration delivers training, products and performance development to 30 newly acquired Holman dealerships
Read More →
Franchises, Throughput Down in First Half
A handful of states see franchise growth through June, while EV sales per store boost overall business in U.S.
Read More →